Yes, that’s the question almost every marketing company asks a candidate in the interview process. I feel that it’s a question that everyone wanting to enter S&M should answer very honestly – not just to the company but to your own self and long before the interviews. After all, at first it seems everything is loaded against the marketing guys – their jobs are the ones which involve a lot of travel in rickety buses and trains (more often than not in sweltering heat and humidity of rural India) and on an average, it pays the lowest compared to other fields. You could comfortably sit all day in an AC and make presentations for a software company instead of suffering in the heat. Or fly executive class from one metro to another and tell one-minute solutions to year-long problems of clients. Why would anyone want to take up Sales and Marketing? At first, the argument seems perfectly logical. But dig a little deeper and you get a different point of view. As one of my friends said, “I can’t sit all day in front of a stupid comp and do the same thing over and over again. I shall get bored. I want to travel, meet people and live my life”. Another one says, “I have a natural flair for talking and interacting with people. I am not a desk-jobber. I can’t do stupid numbers and stupid graphs” So is it just about a personality-profile fit? What else could be a decisive factor? In this post, I try to explore that with my own experience.
If someone had told me couple of years back that I would be entering ‘S&M’ after MBA, I would have probably shrugged it off or just said ‘Yeah! Maybe! U can never tell!’ When I first came to IIM Indore, I had a lot of pre-conceived notions. I had almost made up my mind to go into Finance even before I knew what it held. To be honest, I was just driven by whatever were appearing in the papers at that time – time and again, there were reports of how much money I-bankers made and what glorious, luxurious lives they were leading. So when after the initial few weeks of accounts reality struck, it struck hard. At first, I thought I wasn’t working hard enough. After all, I had topped all my life in almost all subjects. But with more and more single digit scores in quizzes, I not only realized that I had no clue about assets, liabilities and income statements but also despite my best efforts, finance wasn’t coming to me. It was almost as if Finance was laughing at me – “You lowly mortal! What did u think of me?”
I don’t know when but it was sometime during my second term that I decided I was not going to Finance. It was a coming together of a lot of factors – all the banks deciding not to shortlist me during summers, my poor scores in Finance and accounts quizzes and the sheer terror that came over me every time I saw a balance sheet. In hindsight, it was probably too early to call it quits (considering the fact we had learned little ‘real’ finance till then) but at that time it was the right decision.
So at this point, when I was really unsure about what I was going to do came our IRIS event ‘Marksman’. It was basically a marketing strategy game we were organizing as part of our annual inter-college festival. I later realized the game being very similar to a popular branding game marketed to international B-schools for their curricula. The important difference was that this one had been Indianized very well. It was basically about four soap manufacturing companies fighting it across the different regions under various simulated conditions as they attempt to capture market share and increase their brand value. As part of the preparations for the game, I learnt a lot about market research, consumer behavior under different situations – things I would have never learnt in class, at least not in the first year. The game was one of the important reasons that I turned towards marketing.
By the time I was in my third term, I had more or less settled with marketing. And this was what worried me the most – I wasn’t very sure whether I wanted to do marketing but it was looking like the right choice. The bigger dilemma came when we had to select our electives for the fourth term before we went for our internships. Knowing my dilemma, one of my good friends suggested I take marketing courses but keep a couple of Fin courses in the ‘float’ option just in case I changed my mind after my internship. Although my summer internship didn’t give me any first hand experience in sales or distribution, I got to know a little about the way sales actually worked by observing some of the managers there. I just felt that I could do the sale they were trying to make – it sort of reassured my own abilities to handle sales. I was actually able to understand where exactly the manager was making a mistake. And I became more confident.
In second year, with the help of some good courses and better Profs, I begun to deliberate more about marketing as a career. Although there was a small dilemma till the beginning of placements,there was just a gut feel which asked me to go ahead with it and so here Iam - a fresh MBA about to jump into S&M. So where exactly in the middle of all this did I make that choice to enter marketing? Which is that one point which tipped it over? The truth is I don’t think there was one. I can’t point to a single day and say that was when it happened. It was just a slow-build up until finally one day I realized I will probably enjoy doing this and I will be good at it. This might not be the case with everyone – I have seen people who knew that they have always wanted to do marketing. Some others have always thought it as a natural fit for their personality. I guess, in the end, what really matters is that u should be convinced yourself and clearly know why you are taking it up. Salaries or Big names don’t matter; it’s better to take up something that you know you will like doing – Conventional wisdom, yes, but worth recollecting and remembering!
6 comments:
I completely agree with you that you have to do what you like. And in any case, even if you get into something you don't like - for force of peer pressure and saalaries etc - you will end up shifting to something you like.
What I disagree with is your friend's comment that IT jobs are 'sitting in front of a stupidd com and doing the same thing again and again'. Sittin in front of a com is a choice that's left to you - and it's everyone's like or dislike, but IT jobs don't mean 'doing the saame thing over and over again'. Infact from what I see, IT jobs are ones that really keep you on toes and gives you different things. People rarely do the same thing 1-2 years after what they started with.
But yes, IT jobs are in plenty and aren't so-cool and they probably don't pay so much in the long run, and there are too many jobs and too many variations and you might not know what you get into without actually getting into, but saying 'doing the saame thing again and again' is pure misconception, to say the leaast. :)
i take umbrage at ur IT job comment [:P]...i know exactly wht i am getting into..a chill life ..hopefully
I completely agree with your point that whatever gives you kick, u should be working tirelessly on that life long! There is a chance you will win laurels for whatever u achieve in a job you love to do! However, getting into something which u dont like will create more problems in ur life leave aside career.
Coming to the point that Govar raised about IT jobs, i also agree that saying an IT job is simply a robotic/repeatable/monotonous job, is more of a blanket statement!
However, i do agree that if you have a flair for brands...for creative stuff...then IT(more of B2B) might not be your cup of tea. What will you do in say an infosys to sell your business solution? Attach it with an emotion as FMCG do? or attach it with an idea which you created while travelling?
An infosys/HP/IBM will say that we have ABCD certifications, we figure in XYZ best...lists, we know the sector...blah blah...but not a single idea which makes you really go crazy while say selling an AXE deodrant!
Google can be an exception, but that again is more of a B2C company these days...
I have myslef worked on the delivery side of IT for around 4 years, and i didnt feel a kick while even working client-side, it was too lifeless for me (Dbs, platforms, interfaces...) even discussing business requirements..
I can go on and on and on...on this. However, i would say S&M is for the guys who more often than not use their left brain! Marketers add spice to your life(real lives!!), though business analysts arent adding much lesser value either!
~nits
@Govar - That comment of my friend's must be just viewed from his perspective. He just feels that IT jobs are like that.
I have nothing against IT jobs. Each job has its own set of takers and the ones who aren't taking up a particular profile try to put it down just to reassure themselves of their choice. In the end, as we all agree, the job must be something we enjoy doing.
@ Simba - :)
@nits - Although I agree that the excitement is more in FMCG, it isn't totally bleak for a marketer in the IT side. Some of the branding stuff attempted by top Indian IT companies today are really exciting. They are trying to move from the outsourcing image built over the years to a consultant image and its going to be both difficult and exciting for a marketer doing that.
Whoa! good one. Though it more looked liked an exception which pulled you to marketing than anything. However, it is nice to hear someone really enjoying it. It is a tough life and would like to know more after two-three years than in the next 6 months.
Have done it once. You would be surprised at the poor knowledge of people on products and the sheer requirement of growing bottomline at any cost. I finally got disgusted and disappointed!
@Mahesh - exception? maybe! Anyways, I wouldn't need 3 years to decide. I should have the answer for u in a year's time.
Post a Comment